A book review and a love letter

Let’s get one thing straight before we start. I don’t like Ezra Klein. I love Ezra Klein. Not because people say the neoliberal heartthrob is as charming as he is handsome (although all those things are true!) and not because I often agree with positions of the center-left technocrat (I actively try to read people I disagree with, in order to avoid bubble-think).

No, my affinity for Ezra begins over a decade ago, when he was an obscure blogger and I was one of his very few readers. At the time, Ezra was one of a tiny number of writers doing serious policy analysis – evaluating legislation as empirically as a management consultant would evaluate a client’s budget. Considering the media environment at the time, this was pretty radical. News outlets would either explore the policy through fact-free hyper-normative opinion pieces, or do the sort of “straight-reporting” that would refuse to say 2+2 = 4 in order to appear unbiased. It’s hard to overstate how vacuous all of this could get – and how different what Ezra was doing was. While respectable outlets were all ‘Supporters say Medicare Part D will be very expensive. Opponents say it will be cheap. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯’,  Klein would be all ‘the best analysis from the CBO and more independent economists indicate that Medicare part D will cost the federal government around $40bn this year and proceed with a CAGR between 3-5 percent for the next ten years.” It’s for this reason nerds like me fell in love with him. Indeed, my admiration was so deep that when I met him at a DC halloween party in 2006, I fan-girled so hard at the man dressed like the book “What’s the Matter with Kansas?” he asked me if I was OK with genuine concern.

Since then, Ezra has risen from obscurity to prominence. At his recent talk at UPenn, I expressed shock to a fellow MBA that, 15 minutes before the event began, all the seats had already been filled and it was standing-room only. She was less surprised, and noted that he is now “such a cultural figure.” This likely due to his role in founding Vox.com, an amazing news site so replete with charts and graphs, wonks all over the world now swoon for its founder.

It’s this high-regard in which I and others hold him that leaves something nagging at me. My man-crush, who has lived his life with a commitment to evidence and whose intellect is obvious to all he encounters, has been a less-than-stellar forecaster of elections. I actually do not think predicting political races is a particularly valuable media product; I find the policy analysis and context provided to news stories of Vox “explainers” to be much more valuable. Still, the fact that an obviously talented individual, who has spent his entire career working in politics, would make such a misguided forecast as to predict that Marco Rubio would win the GOP primary bugs me. Not because of what it tells me about Ezra, but what it reveals about the human mind, institutions, and culture.

This is where the book Superforecasting comes into play. Written by Penn’s own genius prognosticator Phil Tetlock, the work is chock full of lessons on prediction. One recurring theme is the failure of expertise. The most striking example is ‘The Good Judgement Project’. Tetlock gathered predictions from more than 20,000 educated and curious citizens with no background in foreign affairs, and instructed them to make predictions about a variety of current events. Placing their forecasts into an algorithm, he came up with a set of GJP predictions and entered them into a government forecasting tournament. GJP won – even though their competitors were intelligence professionals who were not only career experts but people with access to classified information the GJP was not privy to.

If novices can seemingly out-forecast experts, what does that say about expertise? If this occurs in the most serious circumstances like intelligence work, what does that say about a number of human endeavours where forecasting is vital? The stability of financial markets is an obvious example, and we’ve seen in recent history a novice ex-medical professional outperform the entire net expertise of big banks in his prediction of the 2008 housing crash (UnFun Fact: Michael Burry is now predicting a giant global water shortage).

Of Tetlock’s thousands of novices, 2% stuck out as highly and consistently accurate. He deems these people “superforecasters”, and attempts to glean lessons from them. What he learns then recommends seems intuitive – break down an issue into discrete parts, think probabilistically, minimize internal biases and utilize data and logic, keep a record or your predictions and review for lessons learned, etc.

I think all of Tetlock’s recommended behaviors are good practices, but I don’t think they would really be new to professionals. Did the CIA experts who said there was a “slam-dunk” case for Iraq having WMD really not understand the importance of minimizing internal biases? Did the bankers who invested in subprime loans really not understand the importance of breaking an issue down into discrete parts? Did Nate Silver, the statistician who literally became famous for mocking political talking-heads for ignoring polling data prior to the 2008-election, really not understand the importance of utilizing data when he predicted a Trump collapse?

So here’s my theory as to why novices often get it right and experts often fail. Exerts by definition have expertise, which helps them get picked up by establishments. Establishments often have perverse incentives, for a variety of reasons, to offer untrue projections. Moreover, these tendencies are exacerbated by groupthink, which even the most aware expert is susceptible to because they are part of establishments. And establishments inherently include socialization, which causes the human mind to defer to a consensus that they might not agree with were they not surrounded by it.

I asked Ezra at his recent talk whether he thought the reason his forecasts were inaccurate and mine (I’ve predicted the rise of both Obama and Trump when both were laughed at by pundits and in single-digits on the prediction markets) have been amazing might be because I’m on the outside (I don’t work in politics, policy, or media) and he is part of the establishment, thereby sucked-in by groupthink. His answer?

“I’m going to turn over all of my investments to you.”

Related posts

418 Comments

  1. Pingback: The Wharton Journal on “A book review and a love letter” | SUPERFORECASTING IN ACTION

  2. Pingback: xmt85c4wx5ctwxw3tcerthve56

  3. Pingback: http://falschgeldkaufen.blogspot.com/2017/01/wo-kann-ich-falschgeld-kaufen.html

  4. Pingback: دانلود قسمت هشتم شهرزاد دوم

  5. Pingback: دانلود شهرزاد قسمت هفتم فصل دوم

  6. Pingback: دانلود شهرزاد قسمت هشتم فصل دوم

  7. Pingback: قیمت پنجره

  8. Pingback: دانلود قسمت 12 عاشقانه

  9. Pingback: Mia Malkova

  10. Pingback: Allie Haze

  11. Pingback: Rayna Rose

  12. Pingback: دانلود شهرزاد قسمت هفتم فصل دوم

  13. Pingback: hampton bay ceiling fan blog

  14. Pingback: lesbian porn xxx

  15. Pingback: skidsteer repairs

  16. Pingback: پنجره

  17. Pingback: دانلود قسمت دوازه عاشقانه

  18. Pingback: Loyola College for Sale by CollegeDunia

  19. Pingback: دانلود قسمت پنجم شهرزاد دوم

  20. Pingback: دانلود قسمت سوم شهرزاد دوم

  21. Pingback: bypass windows 7 admin password

  22. Pingback: دانلود قسمت اول فصل دوم شهرزاد

  23. Pingback: دانلود قسمت 13 عاشقانه

  24. Pingback: porno gratis

  25. Pingback: porno gratis

  26. Pingback: Antonaccio

  27. Pingback: videos porno

  28. Pingback: porno

  29. Pingback: porno

  30. Pingback: porno gratis

  31. Pingback: porno gratis

  32. Pingback: porno

  33. Pingback: porno

  34. Pingback: فروش پنجره دو سه جداره

  35. Pingback: ساخت پنجره دوجداره

  36. Pingback: car shipping

  37. Pingback: Facial Spa Services Oakland Park

  38. Pingback: Acne Facial Treatments Deerfield Beach

  39. Pingback: Acne Facial Treatments Lauderdale-by-the-Sea

  40. Pingback: Facial Spa Services Davie

  41. Pingback: دانلود موزیک

  42. Pingback: فروش توری پنجره دوجداره

  43. Pingback: groin support wrap

  44. Pingback: casino gamble video poker

  45. Pingback: دانلود قسمت پنجم شهرزاد

  46. Pingback: rate compares

  47. Pingback: the url of the site

  48. Pingback: دانلود قسمت هفتم شهرزاد دوم

  49. Pingback: free clash royale coins

  50. Pingback: thin led recessed light

  51. Pingback: coin-banks cryptocurrency

  52. Pingback: coin-banks

  53. Pingback: bitcoin investment coin-banks

  54. Pingback: bitcoin trading

  55. Pingback: DraftKings DFS

  56. Pingback: satinelle

  57. Pingback: mdansby software

  58. Pingback: vpm

  59. Pingback: cheapest golf clubs

  60. Pingback: anime

  61. Pingback: کول دانلول

  62. Pingback: پنجره دوجداره

  63. Pingback: دانلود سریال شهرزاد قسمت 15 پانزده

  64. Pingback: working clash royale hack

  65. Pingback: http://

  66. Pingback: xsc.jlau.edu.cn/Bbs/home.php?mod=space&uid=1782223&do=profile&from=space

  67. Pingback: Dresser As Changing Table

  68. Pingback: دانلود سریال شهرزاد قسمت 16

  69. Pingback: دانلود شهرزاد قسمت 16

  70. Pingback: Roofing Long Island

  71. Pingback: Click This Link

  72. Pingback: دانلود فیلم

  73. Pingback: دانلود قسمت دوم سریال عالیجناب

  74. Pingback: clique aqui

  75. Pingback: pepa pig

  76. Pingback: پنجره ضد سرقت ترک

  77. Pingback: دانلود

  78. Pingback: Bollywood Movies Trailer

  79. Pingback: pepp

  80. Pingback: شرکت تولیدی پنجره دوجداره المانی

  81. Pingback: save money

  82. Pingback: Upholstery Cleaning fort hood TX

  83. Pingback: rhymes for kids

  84. Pingback: kids songs

  85. Pingback: la home

  86. Pingback: buy home

  87. Pingback: دانلود فیلم

  88. Pingback: marketing network

  89. Pingback: Double

  90. Pingback: how to buy bitcoins

  91. Pingback: Pixel Gun hack

  92. Pingback: авто-ключар

  93. Pingback: baby song

  94. Pingback: پنجره دوجداره

  95. Pingback: دانلود

  96. Pingback: قیمت پنجره دوجداره

  97. Pingback: پنجره

  98. Pingback: back to school

  99. Pingback: شرکت تولیدی پنجره دوجداره

  100. Pingback: اموزش ساخت پنجره دوجداره

  101. Pingback: IELTS preparation in Karachi

  102. Pingback: Mitch McConnell

  103. Pingback: walmartone login

  104. Pingback: Surrey Limo

  105. Pingback: dominoqq99

  106. Pingback: https://trello.com/jamesstephenson23

  107. Pingback: glutathione

  108. Pingback: buy views on youtube

  109. Pingback: فیلم اکسیدان

  110. Pingback: دانلود

  111. Pingback: window

  112. Pingback: window price

  113. Pingback: iron stair parts

  114. Pingback: Learn English with Songs

  115. Pingback: پنجره دوجداره

  116. Pingback: پنجره دوجداره

  117. Pingback: فیلم

  118. Pingback: Bad Spiderman

  119. Pingback: karaj

  120. Pingback: gardening

  121. Pingback: usi tech info

  122. Pingback: unique products

  123. Pingback: maintenance

  124. Pingback: click here

  125. Pingback: Fuzjn Project 365

  126. Pingback: restauração auditiva

  127. Pingback: Low cost Bathroom & Kitchen remodeling contractor Montclair

  128. Pingback: gay porn

  129. Pingback: uk top 40 music chart

  130. Pingback: دانلود

  131. Pingback: karajupvc

  132. Pingback: bowl

  133. Pingback: Testbank

  134. Pingback: download

  135. Pingback: download

  136. Pingback: download

  137. Pingback: دانلود فیلم

  138. Pingback: carte grise en ligne

  139. Pingback: garden bridges San Jose

  140. Pingback: read now

  141. Pingback: ?S????S ??????

  142. Pingback: Togel Online

  143. Pingback: Wish My Wife Would Swing

  144. Pingback: personnel consultancy

  145. Pingback: 10 Facts About USA Military

  146. Pingback: buy hacklink google

  147. Pingback: دانلود فیلم نهنگ عنبر

  148. Pingback: vehicle shippers

  149. Pingback: Agen Bola

  150. Pingback: textbook test bank

  151. Pingback: learn colors with balls machine

  152. Pingback: Private Tour

  153. Pingback: https://www.behance.net/infob0324f42

  154. Pingback: payday loans

  155. Pingback: buy illegal seo

  156. Pingback: love spells to control a man

  157. Pingback: Go Here

  158. Pingback: آینه بغل

  159. Pingback: دانلود فیلم رایگان

  160. Pingback: دانلود سریال شهرزاد

  161. Pingback: دانلود فیلم

  162. Pingback: Stroller canopy

  163. Pingback: Android Porn App

  164. Pingback: stroller accessories

  165. Pingback: Schluesseldienst Koeln

  166. Pingback: dealfeed

  167. Pingback: Bandar Judi Bola Selalu Online

  168. Pingback: maximainvestments

  169. Pingback: porn movie

  170. Pingback: mobile porn

  171. Pingback: Segala Macam Judi Olahraga

  172. Pingback: ΑΘΗΝΑ ΞΕΝΟΔΟΧΕΙΑ

  173. Pingback: pirater un compte facebook

  174. Pingback: wireless headphones

  175. Pingback: daily horoscope and lucky numbers

  176. Pingback: Oddsmonkey

  177. Pingback: 2 فیلم نهنگ عنبر

  178. Pingback: Oddsmonkey

  179. Pingback: Oddsmonkey

  180. Pingback: consumerhealthdigest.com/prostate/prostara.html

  181. Pingback: Black Friday Coupons

  182. Pingback: www.consumerhealthdigest

  183. Pingback: mobile

  184. Pingback: http://bit.ly/shane-perry-marketing

  185. Pingback: Hakukoneoptimointi Espoo

  186. Pingback: cases accessories

  187. Pingback: wesley

  188. Pingback: sexmag

  189. Pingback: Full Report

  190. Pingback: https://apokryphiaart.jimdo.com/2017/09/26/find-safe-cosmetic-and-beauty-products-online/

  191. Pingback: 3 Piece Women's Sexy Nurse Lingerie Sexy Adult Fancy Dress Costume Outfit

  192. Pingback: https://rocketdock.com/user/193890

  193. Pingback: buy cialis online

  194. Pingback: estate planning the woodlands

  195. Pingback: it recycling companies essex

  196. Pingback: recycling computers bracknell

  197. Pingback: click this

  198. Pingback: i need an essay written for me

  199. Pingback: why not look here

  200. Pingback: Peter Schatzberg Florida

  201. Pingback: bunk bed singapore

  202. Pingback: Breastfeeding scarf

  203. Pingback: Hearing

  204. Pingback: sex polls

  205. Pingback: Yöresel Antep

  206. Pingback: google blackhat free

  207. Pingback: michael kors usa

  208. Pingback: Essential Oils

  209. Pingback: real money casino games

  210. Pingback: progressive car insurance login

  211. Pingback: Proper Order

  212. Pingback: biciclette elettriche bosch

  213. Pingback: michael kors sydney

  214. Pingback: Pinganillo

  215. Pingback: anthony morrison

  216. Pingback: personal injury lawyer

  217. Pingback: online casino

  218. Pingback: best porn sites

  219. Pingback: United Airlines Business Class Tickets

  220. Pingback: free porn sites

  221. Pingback: deeeep.io wiki

  222. Pingback: Luft til vann vamrepumpe

  223. Pingback: scriptfacebook html

  224. Pingback: porno

  225. Pingback: best free porn sites

  226. Pingback: walmartone

  227. Pingback: Personalized Video From Santa Claus

  228. Pingback: payday loan

  229. Pingback: btc

  230. Pingback: eksotika.net

  231. Pingback: taylorsirishnight.com

  232. Pingback: best porn site

  233. Pingback: homemade porn

  234. Pingback: phone case

  235. Pingback: porn list

  236. Pingback: www.86lights.com

  237. Pingback: Token

  238. Pingback: HD PORN MOVIES DOWNLOAD

  239. Pingback: buy bitcoins online

  240. Pingback: online business

  241. Pingback: walmart1

  242. Pingback: visit this site right here

  243. Pingback: her explanation

  244. Pingback: go to the website

  245. Pingback: fake gucci bags

  246. Pingback: excel tutorial

  247. Pingback: excel

  248. Pingback: skin bleaching

  249. Pingback: wedding dresses Toronto

  250. Pingback: managed dedicated servers

  251. Pingback: دانلود اینه بغل

  252. Pingback: http://sexmake.com/

  253. Pingback: payday loan

  254. Pingback: Vancouver BC

  255. Pingback: wordpress help

  256. Pingback: Free Chrome Extensions 2018

  257. Pingback: ร้านทำผม กรุงเทพ

  258. Pingback: kitchen-cabinet-hardwares.com

  259. Pingback: child custody attorney

  260. Pingback: sell for free uk

  261. Pingback: matthew pillmore

  262. Pingback: drone-works

  263. Pingback: geico auto insurance

  264. Pingback: typing application

  265. Pingback: licensed moneylender

  266. Pingback: cbd studies

  267. Pingback: cannabis oil for adhd

  268. Pingback: תפילין מהודרות

  269. Pingback: purchase cbd oil

  270. Pingback: green tea chinese

  271. Pingback: Cheap insurance

  272. Pingback: sextus

  273. Pingback: insurance quotes for car and home

  274. Pingback: love

  275. Pingback: Sellanymobile

  276. Pingback: vitamins

  277. Pingback: Ethereum

  278. Pingback: More Info

  279. Pingback: cazzo nella figa

  280. Pingback: Cheap Oakleys for Sale

  281. Pingback: white label casino

  282. Pingback: buy china goods

  283. Pingback: בשר בד"ץ בכפר שלם

  284. Pingback: www.pcmunkey.net

  285. Pingback: Red Tea Detox Review

  286. Pingback: دانلود شهرزاد سوم

  287. Pingback: most sensual cruises

  288. Pingback: real jordans

  289. Pingback: anthony robbins London

  290. Pingback: instagram hack

  291. Pingback: more

  292. Pingback: MCA

  293. Pingback: lainaa 1000

  294. Pingback: she said

  295. Pingback: walmartone sign in

  296. Pingback: https://helios7blog.wordpress.com/2018/01/16/best-mobile-laptop-and-gaming-repair-services-west-yorkshire-uk/ {Helios7blog.wordpress.com|have a peek at this web-site|Source Blog|have a peek here|Check This Out|helios7blog.wordpress.com|this contact form|n

  297. Pingback: 192.168.l.l

  298. Pingback: cunt

  299. Pingback: boiler repair camden

  300. Pingback: top pornsites

  301. Pingback: top porn sites

  302. Pingback: دانلود شهرزاد قسمت سوم فصل سوم

  303. Pingback: Sears Headquarters Corporate Office Phone Number

  304. Pingback: شهرزاد قسمت چهارم

  305. Pingback: transfer services

  306. Pingback: acidity during pregnancy first trimester

  307. Pingback: Fliesenleger München

  308. Pingback: https://sydneynewbornphotographysite.yolasite.com

  309. Pingback: http://go.parvanweb.ir/index.php?url=http://blogoszybkichsamochodach.bloog.pl/id,335423019,title,Filmik-z-gry-Need-For-Speed-Nitro,index.html

  310. Pingback: judi dadu lewat hp android

  311. Pingback: Heizung

  312. Pingback: Read More Here

  313. Pingback: business directory submission sites

  314. Pingback: Executive Taxi Coventry

  315. Pingback: Withdraw Bitcoin to Bank Account

  316. Pingback: دانلود سریال شهرزاد

  317. Pingback: Full Report

  318. Pingback: Purple Mattress Dangerous Powder

  319. Pingback: HOLE DISTANCE(76MM)

  320. Pingback: sex webcams

  321. Pingback: https://membership.nra.org/Join/Annuals

  322. Pingback: Crypto Currency

  323. Pingback: http://pornofollies.com/

  324. Pingback: take surveys for cash demo

  325. Pingback: http://www.1-2-3-webportal.de/

  326. Pingback: Asbestos Watch Adelaide Service Asbestos Removal

  327. Pingback: Asbestos Watch Perth Service Asbestos Testing

  328. Pingback: porn tapes gratis

  329. Pingback: reputation protect

  330. Pingback: http://www.hardware-online-stores.com

  331. Pingback: nude red bottoms

  332. Pingback: Situs Poker Online

  333. Pingback: PDF Files

  334. Pingback: abogado accidentes

  335. Pingback: houses for sale in lancaster ca

  336. Pingback: Alive After the Fall Review

  337. Pingback: Pot O'Dongs Eva Notty Carolina Sweets

  338. Pingback: Cheap Green Bay Packers Jerseys

  339. Pingback: MILF Amber Jayne What's Good For The Goose

  340. Pingback: over at this website

  341. Pingback: david sammon

  342. Pingback: matthew pillmore

  343. Pingback: top article

  344. Pingback: check this out

  345. Pingback: christian louboutin over the knee boots replica

  346. Pingback: https://www.google.com.mx/url?sa=t&source=web&url=https://www.forbiddenplaygroundxxx.com

  347. Pingback: lahore call girls

  348. Pingback: Internação Compulsória

  349. Pingback: visit

  350. Pingback: same day cash advance

  351. Pingback: read what he said

  352. Pingback: 15 Minute Manifestation Review

  353. Pingback: this hyperlink

  354. Pingback: click this

  355. Pingback: drugs

  356. Pingback: https://www.google.com.mx/url?sa=t&source=web&url=https://www.draftkingsmaster.com

  357. Pingback: http://pornobis.net/

  358. Pingback: Delmar Dingmann

  359. Pingback: https://issuu.com/johnmekio

  360. Pingback: escort

  361. Pingback: Lån

  362. Pingback: cheap ray bans sunglasses

  363. Pingback: discoteche versilia

  364. Pingback: weight loss system

  365. Pingback: Arijit Singh

  366. Pingback: Viagra Sans Ordonnance

  367. Pingback: Nâng Mũi S Line

  368. Pingback: schlong

  369. Pingback: laptop disposal

  370. Pingback: Pazaruvane online

  371. Pingback: Elliott Wave WXY Pattern

  372. Pingback: Rich Fucks Part 2 Bridgette B Kristen Scott Honey Gold Xander Corvus

  373. Pingback: stormy's secret stormy daniels keiran lee

  374. Pingback: Radiant Booty 2 Abella Danger Markus Dupree

  375. Pingback: Phẫu Thuật Hàm Hô JW

  376. Pingback: Bengali movies download

  377. Pingback: siófok taxi

  378. Pingback: click here

  379. Pingback: blogging

  380. Pingback: computer recycling companies

  381. Pingback: buy viagra

  382. Pingback: SAP Accounts Payable for Beginers

  383. Pingback: window blinds cellular

  384. Pingback: shades.com

  385. Pingback: Whatsapp status

  386. Pingback: aaron woodman real estate

  387. Pingback: fag

  388. Pingback: see it here

  389. Pingback: screwing

  390. Pingback: frases para facebook

  391. Pingback: whore

  392. Pingback: James Vertzayias

  393. Pingback: jackoff

  394. Pingback: discoteche forte dei marmi

  395. Pingback: dry lips routine

  396. Pingback: capodanno in versilia

  397. Pingback: James Vertzayias

  398. Pingback: Citizenship by investment

  399. Pingback: hoar

  400. Pingback: دستگاه مهرسازی ارزان

  401. Pingback: XXX PORN

  402. Pingback: crypto news Black Hat Forum

  403. Pingback: Unopar EAD

  404. Pingback: Discover More

  405. Pingback: All Blacks Store

  406. Pingback: Persian Businesses

  407. Pingback: Scottsdale mortgage broker

  408. Pingback: estate agent tenerife

  409. Pingback: winnipeg gym

  410. Pingback: yoga teacher training

  411. Pingback: best car accident attorney

  412. Pingback: skank

  413. Pingback: Farsi Translation

  414. Pingback: qufu shaolin kung fu school cost

  415. Pingback: Bakery classes at Vocotionz

  416. Pingback: hole

  417. Pingback: drone works zac davis

  418. Pingback: live sports streams

Top